Search articles


Audi and Mini offer their compact five-doors with brawny 2,0-litre engines. Which is the best premium, small hot hatch?

It’s a bit of a neglected market niche, the one for small hot hatches. Ford has chosen not to import the Fiesta ST; the Renault Clio RS is on its way out with no replacement announced; and both Opel and Peugeot are notable for the local absence of OPC and GTi badges. Yet, there are green shoots, too: the Volkswagen Polo GTI has gained a strong following and both Audi and Mini offer upmarket alternatives to those buyers who want their small hot hatch imbued with premium appeal (or who are looking to buy down from their speedy A3s, Golfs and so on).

Here we pit the brand-new A1 Sportback 40 TFSI against the recently refreshed Cooper S 5-door to find out which vehicle strikes the best balance between driving thrills and that golden measure of a successful hot hatch: everyday ease of use.

Design

The A1 comfortably takes round one. Typically Audi in its geometric forms, the A1 is infused with such delightful details as a vent-studded nose paying homage to the iconic Ur-Quattro of the 1980s, racy 18-inch alloys on this press unit (equally stylish 17-inchers are standard) and angular C-pillars contrasting neatly with a dark roof should a brighter body colour be chosen instead of this vehicle’s conservative Mythos Black. LED headlamps are standard on this flagship 40 TFSI model, as are Audi’s dynamic turn indicators which swipe rather than flash. Hot hatch styling cues are taken care of by red brake callipers, an S line body kit and a rear spoiler.

The Mini, meanwhile, is curiously sensitive to viewing angle. Seen from straight ahead, it looks great thanks to its signature faux bonnet scoop, oversized LED headlamps and protruding bumper. Viewed in profile, however, and it’s impossible to ignore the odd proportions; the rear doors simply look too short. If an added smidge of practicality isn’t a big concern, opt for the more poised three-door and save a few thousand, too.

Hop inside and the tables turn. Where an Audi would normally win an interior quality assessment in a comparative test, the A1 proves the German carmaker isn’t infallible. We mentioned in a previous test of the 35 TFSI that some surfaces aren’t quite befitting of a vehicle sporting the four rings and that’s even truer in the pricier 40 TFSI. The door cards are the main offenders. While we have no issue with hard plastics when they’re great quality, the A1’s door panels don’t look and feel up to the automaker’s usual standard. Thankfully, the textured dashboard top feels great, the ambient lighting surrounding the vents is a classy touch and the cloth covering the seats is superior quality.

The Mini, meanwhile, is more consistent in creating an impression of build integrity. Dense plastics are found on the door tops where your elbows rest and this test unit felt notably solid despite the firm suspension doing its best to undo the designers’ good work. Furthering the positive impression are sports seats covered in optional Dinamica/leather trim which invites touching but costs a painful R25 300; roughly textured grey cloth is standard.

What the A1 lacks in instant tactile appeal, it counters with a broadly more usable interior environment. Rear legroom measures 21 mm more than the Mini’s, while all occupants have more headroom too. The boot’s 32 litres larger, too.

Both hatches boast excellent driving positions. The steering columns align with the drivers’ seats (which sounds like an odd thing to mention but you may be surprised how many vehicles have offset driving positions), the chairs drop deep into the cockpits and the steering wheels adjust generously for rake and reach. While the Mini’s seating position certainly feels sportier with its higher cowl and more reclined default setting, the Audi offers clearer sightlines and easier access to most controls.

Both vehicles are well equipped, as befitting their near-half-a-million-rand price tags. They offer automatic climate control, feature-rich infotainment systems, voice control, and light and rain sensors. The Mini adds park-distance control (a R10 500 option on the Audi which bundles in automatic parking), while the A1 sports a digital instrumentation cluster.

Performance

On paper, the A1 40 TFSI and Cooper S are evenly matched. Each boasts a 2,0-litre turbopetrol engine, the Audi’s familiar from the Polo GTI and the Mini’s shared with a number of BMW Group products. The A1 offers outputs of 147 kW and 320 N.m of torque from 1 500 r/min through 4 400 r/min, while the Cooper S’ forced-induction powerplant sports 141 kW and 280 N.m of torque between 1 250 and 4 600 r/min. The former’s engine is connected to a six-speed dual-clutch transmission, while the Brit adds a ratio (its dual-clutcher being the most notable drivetrain change in the last round of facelifts). Thanks to a kerb weight some 26 kg lighter than the Mini and that extra 6 kW/40 N.m, the A1 sprinted to 100 km/h 0,14 seconds quicker. By 140 km/h, that gap had widened to 0,23 seconds.

The Audi maintained its advantage in-gear, where it needed 0,33 seconds less to bound from 80 to 120 km/h. In real-world conditions, however, that difference is undetectable. Both hot hatches offer instant punch, their engines feeling alert and strong. The dual-clutch ‘boxes are equally well matched; while the Mini’s Steptronic system is slightly snappier in low-speed manoeuvring, the Audi’s S tronic unit provides quicker changes when charging along a mountain pass.

Braking-wise, the Audi is the clear winner, requiring a brisk 2,74 seconds to come to a halt across 10 punishing emergency stops. The Mini needed 0,24 seconds and 3,33 metres extra. Pedal responses are confidence-inspiring, with the Cooper S again offering a smidge more progression than the A1’s initially sharper pedal response.

Dynamics

It’s here where the two start diverging. The Audi is undoubtedly the better daily driver, with a composed ride caught out only by the most abrupt ridges and scars. It stays flat, rebounds quickly and seems unflustered. It’s an impressive showing considering sports suspension is standard but adaptive damping does play its part. It’s more refined than the Mini, suppressing wind noise well at cruising speed. The augmented engine sound, however, had some testers reaching for the audio system’s volume button...

The Mini, meanwhile, offers firmer springs and very little travel, making for a busy ride when the surface turns choppy. That said, the damping is really polished, with the vehicle rarely losing composure. It’s fantastic fun on a smooth, snaky pass, where quick steering, resolute body control and limpet front-end grip funnel into a dynamic package that feels more engaging than the composure-über-alles Audi. The Mini’s engine is more likeable, too; there’s more top-end fizz and a natural-sounding, induction-heavy soundtrack.

TEST SUMMARY

The Audi pips the Mini by virtue of its polished driving manners, stronger performance, better economy on our fuel route and more usable cockpit. It’s a pity perceived quality has taken a knock, making it vulnerable to the mechanically similar Polo GTI at about R90k less. Still, the interior is largely a success and the driving experience is such that the A1 40 TFSI promises to be a rewarding commuter.

Nevertheless, the Mini is more of an experience, more of the time. Certainly, it occasionally frustrates, especially on those weekdays when its haphazard control layout, firmer seats and choppier ride aren’t appreciated. However, every other drive in the Cooper S is rendered an event thanks to the darty steering, fizzy engine and grippy chassis. Five years after its launch, this generation of the Mini has lost none of its appeal.

Audi A1 Sportback 40 TFSI S line S tronic: 78/100
Mini Cooper S 5-door Steptronic: 77/100

Our Top 12 Best Buys small hatchback winner features here in facelifted five-door form...

You can’t really miss them, those Union Jack-patterned brakelamps on the latest Mini hatchback. They’re a small part of both a superficial and mechanical facelift but demand all your attention as you appraise BMW’s smallest car, and they leave no doubts about the origins of the brand. Some members of the CAR test team loved them; others wondered how much it would cost to swap them for pre-facelift units.

Misplaced patriotism aside – at least, at the southern tip of Africa – the facelift nicely updates the four-year-old Mini package, adding to the Cooper S such items as LED headlamps (adaptive tech is optional) with driving lights encircling the entire unit, newly designed alloy wheels, fresh paint colours and graphics, and a piano-black option for the lamp and grille surrounds.

Hop inside and the tweaks continue, with the Visual Boost 6,5-inch touchscreen infotainment screen standard across the Cooper and Cooper S models (optional on the One). Additionally, buyers have the options of new Malt Brown trim and extra lighting in the piano-black trim strips.

On the Cooper S, included in the list price are climate control, sports seats, various driving modes, cloth/leather-combination seat trim and a storage package. The latter can feel like a misnomer applied to a five-door Mini, as storage isn’t exactly plentiful fore and aft. Nor is legroom, which we measured at a class-average 650 mm, but headroom all round is sufficient even with the fitment of a R11 700 dual-sunroof option. This lack of practicality begs the question why buyers wouldn’t simply save themselves some cash and get the three-door (which happens to also look far more balanced without this variant’s too-small rear doors).

Still, plenty of customers do opt for the five-door and they get the usual Mini strengths of excellent perceived quality beyond anything else in the small-hatch segment this side of an Audi A1; a driving position that’s millimetre-perfect (the sports seats offer adjustable under-thigh support, which makes a big difference for taller drivers); and class-leading iDrive connectivity. That scattergun control layout does, however, still demand some time for familiarity to set in.

Unlike the One models, which now boast a three-cylinder 1,5-litre engine in place of the defunct 1,2-litre, the 2,0-litre unit in the Cooper S remains unfettled. What is different is Mini has slotted in a new seven-speed dual-clutch transmission in place of the old six-speeder. The carmaker claims shorter shift times than the torque-converter.

In practice, it’s an alert transmission, displaying little of the low-speed lethargy that often plagues such units. Up the speed and the shifts are indeed quick and smooth.

Which is just as well because, with 141 kW on tap to propel all of 1 340 kg, performance is sprightly rather than electric. The 2,0-litre engine is buttery smooth and even sounds good – with delicious cracks and pops on the overrun with the drive mode set to sport – but it never feels especially potent and lags behind the Volkswagen Polo GTI in most performance-test parameters.

On the road where such figures matter less, the Cooper S is an engaging drive. The engine feels stronger than its performance figures suggest, and the transmission hooks the right gear without resorting to histrionics when the throttle is planted. The steering, however, is the main draw. Nicely hefty but quick, it makes the Cooper S feel alert whether tackling the drag of commuting, or traversing a favourite mountain pass.

That’s allied with close suspension control (so close, in fact, that it sometimes feels as if it’ll run out of travel on a bumpy road; skilfully, it never does) and strong brakes – recording an average stopping time of 2,98 seconds – rendering the Cooper S a fun point-and-shoot machine.

The ride comfort does suffer somewhat from the resolute suspension tuning but it’s entirely liveable day to day and gets caught out only by abrupt scars. As you’d expect from a BMW-backed product, fuel consumption is excellent. We registered 7,80 L/100 km on our standardised fuel route, and even less on a relaxed weekend that took in lots of highway driving at 120 km/h.

TEST SUMMARY

It's a relief every time we get into a Mini and discover BMW hasn't fiddled too much with a winning recipe, the main ingredient of which is fun driving dynamics.

 

In attendance, too, are illogical cabin control placement — although we suspect the quirky layout forms part of the appeal for many buyers — and compromised practicality, especially in five-door form, where tight door apertures and little room in the rear or boot suggest the bigger, R30 000 pricier Cooper S Clubman is the better buy if space is on the list of priorities.

 

The CAR team, however, would happily junk the need for bigger rear seats and opt for the Cooper S three-door, which looks better than this somewhat dumpy five-door and is cheaper to boot. However, with the newest Polo GTI proving an impressive package, will the Mini retain its Top 12 Best Buys crown in January 2019 when we vote for the winners? Based on this test and the improvements made to the Mini range, there might be a few drawn-out debates among CAR's staffers...

 

*From the October 2018 issue of CAR magazine...

 

ROAD TEST SCORE
Hatch MINI Cooper S Hatch 5-door auto
84 / 100
  • Price: R539,554
  • 0-100 km/h: 6.8
  • Power ([email protected]/min): 141 KW @ 4700-6000
  • Torque ([email protected]/min): 280 N.m @ 1250-4600
  • Top speed: 232
  • Claimed cons. (l/100 km): 5.4 l/100 KM's
  • C02 emissions (g/km): 123 g/KM

Comments

All information, pictures, colours, specifications or any other data contained within the www.carmag.co.za website are presented only as a general guide to products and accessories offered by motor manufactures. Although every effort has been made to ensure that all such information is correct and up to date, no guarantee is provided that all such information is reliable, complete, accurate or without error. In some cases pictures of various foreign models may be shown as a guide. All information should be verified by an official dealership.

www.carmag.co.za does not accept any liability for damages of any kind resulting from the access or use of this site and its contents.

If you do not wish to be bound by these Terms you may not access, copy or download any content on this Website as per the CARmag Terms of Use available at carmag.co.za/terms_of_use.html

0 vehicles to be emailed:
To !
From !
To !